SAVE_CONFIG section 'extruder' option 'control' conflicts with included value

General Discussion
1

Basic Information:

Printer Model: Mercury One.1
MCU / Printerboard: Manta M8P/CB1
klippy.logklippy.log (5.6 MB)

Fill out above information and in all cases attach your klippy.log file (use zip to compress it, if too big). Pasting your printer.cfg is not needed
Be sure to check our “Knowledge Base” Category first. Most relevant items, e.g. error messages, are covered there

Describe your issue:

…

Started to run my hot end PID tune for the first time and came across this error when trying to write the SAVE_CONFIG. I know that Klipper doesn’t allow for writing SAVE_CONFIGs to includes, so I moved the extruder section from my EBB36 cfg to the Manta and the same result. I cannot find anything in the configuration that would be conflicting.

Thanks for any help you can offer.

2

For this case please attach all your configs

3

Thanks @Sineos

Here is the Manta config:

# This file contains common pin mappings for the BIGTREETECH Manta M8P
# To use this config, the firmware should be compiled for the
# STM32G0B1 with a "8KiB bootloader" "8 MHz crystal"
# and "USB (on PA11/PA12)" or "CAN bus (on PD12/PD13)".

# See docs/Config_Reference.md for a description of parameters.

[mcu CB1]
serial: /tmp/klipper_host_mcu

[stepper_x]
step_pin: PE2
dir_pin: !PB4
enable_pin: !PC11
microsteps: 16
rotation_distance: 40
endstop_pin: EBBCan: PB6
position_endstop: 260
position_max: 260
homing_speed: 50


[stepper_y]
step_pin: PF12
dir_pin: !PF11
enable_pin: !PB3
microsteps: 16
rotation_distance: 40
endstop_pin: ^PF3
position_endstop: 260
position_max: 260
homing_speed: 50


[stepper_z]
step_pin: PD7
dir_pin: !PD6
enable_pin: !PF10
microsteps: 16
rotation_distance: 8
endstop_pin:probe:z_virtual_endstop
#position_endstop: 0
position_min: -15
position_max: 300
homing_speed: 12
second_homing_speed: 5


[bed_mesh]
speed: 120
horizontal_move_z: 10
mesh_min: 20, 24
mesh_max: 210, 190 # Ender 5 / 5 Pro
#mesh_max: 340, 310 # Ender 5 Plus
probe_count: 5,3

[probe]
pin: EBBCan: PB8 ### Check your board pinout, this is an example pin ###
x_offset: -2
y_offset: 28.75
z_offset: 0
speed: 5 ### I have found it accurate on my setup running as fast as 10, at 16 the accuracy started to degrade ###
samples:1 ### Klicky is accurate enough for a single sample, the remaining lines are not needed if you run a single sample ###
samples_result: median
sample_retract_dist: 2.0
samples_tolerance: 0.01
samples_tolerance_retries: 5

# Motor4
# The M8P only has 4 heater outputs which leaves an extra stepper
# This can be used for a second Z stepper, dual_carriage, extruder co-stepper,
# or other accesory such as an MMU
#[stepper_]
#step_pin: PD3
#dir_pin: PD2
#enable_pin: !PD5
#endstop_pin: PC0
#...

#[extruder]
#step_pin: PC9
#dir_pin: PC8
#enable_pin: !PD1
#microsteps: 16
#rotation_distance: 33.500
#nozzle_diameter: 0.4
#filament_diameter: 1.75
#heater_pin: PE3 # HE0
#sensor_type: EPCOS 100K B57560G104F
#sensor_pin: PA1 # T0
#control: pid
#pid_Kp: 22.2
#pid_Ki: 1.08
#pid_Kd: 114
#min_temp: 0
#max_temp: 250

[extruder]
step_pin: EBBCan: PD0
dir_pin: EBBCan: PD1
enable_pin: !EBBCan: PD2
microsteps: 16
full_steps_per_rotation: 200
rotation_distance: 4.637
nozzle_diameter: 0.400
filament_diameter: 1.750
max_extrude_only_distance: 500
max_extrude_only_velocity: 120
pressure_advance: 0.025                        
pressure_advance_smooth_time: 0.03  
heater_pin: EBBCan: PB13
sensor_type:MAX31865
sensor_pin: EBBCan: PA4
spi_bus: spi1
rtd_nominal_r: 100
rtd_reference_r: 430
rtd_num_of_wires: 2
#sensor_type: PT1000
#sensor_pin: EBBCan: PA3
control: pid
pid_Kp: 21.527
pid_Ki: 1.063
pid_Kd: 108.982
min_temp: 0
max_temp: 280
min_extrude_temp: 190


# Motor6
#[extruder1]
#step_pin: PA10
#dir_pin: PA14
#enable_pin: !PA15
#heater_pin: PB5 # HE1
#sensor_pin: PA2 # T1
#...


# Motor7
#[extruder2]
#step_pin: PD11
#dir_pin: PD9
#enable_pin: !PD15
#heater_pin: PB6 # HE2
#sensor_pin: PA3 # T2
#...

# Motor8
#[extruder3]
#step_pin: PD8
#dir_pin: PC6
#enable_pin: !PC7
#heater_pin: PE1 # HE3
#sensor_pin: PA4 # T3
#...

[heater_bed]
heater_pin: PB7
sensor_type: Generic 3950
sensor_pin: PA0 # TB
control: watermark
min_temp: 0
max_temp: 130

[fan]
pin: PE6

[temperature_fan SoC_fan] 
pin: CB1: gpio79 
#pin:CB1:gpio26 
kick_start_time: 0.8 
off_below: 0.8 
max_power: 1.0 
sensor_type: temperature_host 
control: pid 
min_temp: 0
max_temp: 100 
pid_kp: 1.0
pid_ki: 0.5 
pid_kd: 2.0 
min_speed: 0.0 
max_speed: 0.8 
target_temp: 45

#[heater_fan fan1]
#pin: PE0

#[heater_fan fan2]
#pin: PC12

#[heater_fan fan3]
#pin: PE5

#[heater_fan fan4]
#pin: PE4

#[heater_fan fan5]
#pin: PB8
#tachometer_pin: PC14

#[heater_fan fan6]
#pin: PB9
#tachometer_pin: PC15


[mcu]
canbus_uuid: d0466b5b4c5d


[printer]
kinematics: corexy
max_velocity: 300
max_accel: 3000
max_z_velocity: 5
max_z_accel: 100

########################################
# TMC2209 configuration
########################################

[tmc2209 stepper_x]
uart_pin: PC10
diag_pin: PF3
run_current: 0.800
#stealthchop_threshold: 999999

[tmc2209 stepper_y]
uart_pin: PF13
##diag_pin: PF4
run_current: 0.800
#stealthchop_threshold: 999999

[tmc2209 stepper_z]
uart_pin: PF9
##diag_pin: PF5
run_current: 0.650
#stealthchop_threshold: 999999

#[tmc2209 stepper_]
#uart_pin: PD4
##diag_pin: PC0
#run_current: 0.650
#stealthchop_threshold: 999999

#[tmc2209 extruder]
#uart_pin: PD0
#run_current: 0.800
#stealthchop_threshold: 999999

#[tmc2209 extruder1]
#uart_pin: PF8
#run_current: 0.800
#stealthchop_threshold: 999999

#[tmc2209 extruder2]
#uart_pin: PD14
#run_current: 0.800
#stealthchop_threshold: 999999

#[tmc2209 extruder3]
#uart_pin: PD10
#run_current: 0.800
#stealthchop_threshold: 999999



[board_pins]
aliases:
    # EXP1 header
    EXP1_1=PE9, EXP1_2=PE10,
    EXP1_3=PE11, EXP1_4=PE12,
    EXP1_5=PE13, EXP1_6=PE14,    # Slot in the socket on this side
    EXP1_7=PE15, EXP1_8=PB10,
    EXP1_9=<GND>, EXP1_10=<5V>,

    # EXP2 header
    EXP2_1=PB14, EXP2_2=PB13,
    EXP2_3=PF7, EXP2_4=PB12,
    EXP2_5=PE7, EXP2_6=PB11,      # Slot in the socket on this side
    EXP2_7=PE8, EXP2_8=<RST>,
    EXP2_9=<GND>, EXP2_10=<NC>

# See the sample-lcd.cfg file for definitions of common LCD displays.


# Proximity switch
#[probe]
#pin: PF6

#[output_pin ps_on_pin]
#pin: PC3

#[output_pin pc13_pin]
#pin: PC13

#[neopixel my_neopixel_1]
#pin: PA9

#[neopixel my_neopixel_2]
#pin: PB15

#[hall_filament_width_sensor]
#adc1: PC5
#adc2: PB0

#[adxl345]
#cs_pin: PC4
#spi_bus: spi1

and the EBB36

# This file contains common pin mappings for the BIGTREETECH EBBCan
# Canbus board. To use this config, the firmware should be compiled for the
# STM32G0B1 with "8 MHz crystal" and "USB (on PA11/PA12)" or "CAN bus (on PB0/PB1)".
# The "EBB Can" micro-controller will be used to control the components on the nozzle.

# See docs/Config_Reference.md for a description of parameters.

[mcu EBBCan]

canbus_uuid: f051da4ec249

#[adxl345]
#cs_pin: EBBCan: PB12
#spi_software_sclk_pin: EBBCan: PB10
#spi_software_mosi_pin: EBBCan: PB11
#spi_software_miso_pin: EBBCan: PB2
#axes_map: x,y,z

#[extruder]
#step_pin: EBBCan: PD0
#dir_pin: EBBCan: PD1
#enable_pin: !EBBCan: PD2
#microsteps: 16
#full_steps_per_rotation: 200
#rotation_distance: 4.637
#nozzle_diameter: 0.400
#filament_diameter: 1.750
#max_extrude_only_distance: 500
#max_extrude_only_velocity: 120
#pressure_advance: 0.025                        
#pressure_advance_smooth_time: 0.03  

#heater_pin: EBBCan: PB13
#sensor_type:MAX31865
#sensor_pin: EBBCan: PA4
#spi_bus: spi1
#rtd_nominal_r: 100
#rtd_reference_r: 430
#rtd_num_of_wires: 2
##sensor_type: PT1000
##sensor_pin: EBBCan: PA3
#control: pid
#pid_Kp: 21.527
#pid_Ki: 1.063
#pid_Kd: 108.982
#min_temp: 0
#max_temp: 280
#min_extrude_temp: 190


[tmc2209 extruder]
uart_pin: EBBCan: PA15
stealthchop_threshold: 999999
interpolate: true
run_current: 0.85
sense_resistor: 0.11 
driver_TBL: 0
driver_HEND: 6
driver_HSTRT: 7
driver_TOFF: 4

[fan]
pin: EBBCan: PA1

[heater_fan hotend_fan]
pin: EBBCan: PA0
heater: extruder
heater_temp: 50.0

#[neopixel hotend_rgb]
#pin: EBBCan:PD3

#[bltouch]
#sensor_pin: ^EBBCan:PB8
#control_pin: EBBCan:PB9

#[filament_switch_sensor switch_sensor]
#switch_pin: EBBCan:PB4

#[filament_motion_sensor motion_sensor]
#switch_pin: ^EBBCan:PB3

Printer.cfg

[virtual_sdcard]
path: ~/printer_data/gcodes
[display_status]
[pause_resume]


[include mainsail.cfg]

[include generic-bigtreetech-manta-m8p-v1.1.cfg]

[include sample-bigtreetech-ebb-canbus-v1.2.cfg]

[include OrbiterSensor.cfg]

[include klicky/klicky-probe.cfg]

They are still a mess since I am currently configuring the machine.

4

Maybe I do not understand you correctly:

You have already provided the answer but yet your printer.cfg consist of only includes.

Klipper is only able to update sections in printer.cfg and nowhere else. So, each config section that may contain a “savable” item must be in the printer.cfg.
Or do I miss something?

5

I don’t think so - the need for having the “savable” pieces in printer.cfg gave me a few headaches at the start as well.

6

Hey. Thanks. I misunderstood. I didn’t realize it was literally only to the printer.cfg. Makes sense now.

7

It’s a little wonky for sure. Once the PIDs are set it should still apply as required even though they aren’t in the printer.cfg?

8

I wouldn’t call it “wonky”. It makes perfect sense when you think about it - nobody wants to write code that follows include paths to find where to comment out the previous values.

You can have your PID values anywhere you want but if they’re not in printer.cfg then you can’t update them.

9

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.