General understanding what the value of tap_z_offset does

Basic Information:

Printer Model: voron 2.4 with eddy duo
MCU / Printerboard: BTT octopus MAX EZ
Host / SBC: raspberry pi 5
klippy.log

Fill out above information and in all cases attach your klippy.log file (use zip to compress it, if too big). Pasting your printer.cfg is not needed
Be sure to check our “Knowledge Base” Category first. Most relevant items, e.g. error messages, are covered there

Describe your issue:

i want to know if what i think the tap_z_offset should do is also wat the code in klipper is doing. what i see is the opposite behavior.

so during final step of calibrating my eddy probe i also calibrated the tap_z_offset using the paper test.
i heated the nossle to 125 degrees and the bed to 60 and let it heatsoak.
i then lowered the nossle onto the paper until it you can feel resistance on the paper.
after that i remove the paper and issue the command Z_OFFSET_APPLY_PROBE METHOD=tap.

it taps the bed and gives a value (in my case 0.250) and i save the value.

what i think what klipper is doing is setting a negative offset to 0. 0 should be the paper and -0.250 should be the tap on the bed. so when a tap is preformed like say at 0.2 the actualy 0 value should be 0.250 higher at 0.450 because of the paper?

yet i see it the other way around. i see after de bedmesh etc the nossle scrapping the bed with tap_z_offset=0.250 and with 0 its not doing that, it prints perfectly.

so im trying to understand what the value tap_z_offset actually does. what does it offset from where to where

tap_z_offset is intended to cancel “bias”, that is it.
For whatever reason(s), tap may detect zero repeatedly, but with a “constant” offset.
This “constant” offset can be canceled with tap_z_offset.

There is no built-in helper to do a paper test for the tap, and by so, to call a manual probe test.
Where I would expect that offset is within -0.1..0.1 normally, so it is hard to get it “right” with the paper.
My personal example is tap_z_offset = -0.085

Otherwise, the intended way to do so may look like that:

SET_Z_FROM_PROBE MEHTOD=tap
BED_MESH_CALIBRATE ADAPTIVE=1 METHOD=tap
<print first layer + babby stepping>
Z_OFFSET_APPLY_PROBE METHOD=tap

Hope that helps,
-Timofey


  1. Eddy: compensate bed_mesh with tap

Hi, it helps to understand it.

so from the use SET_Z_FROM_PROBE MEHTOD=tap is then stating 0 = bed.
i was under the understanding that Z_OFFSET_APPLY_PROBE METHOD=tap would also use the bed as a some sort of 0 reference. but its not.
its using the stored G28 Z reference as absolute 0 which is why i get strange values.

my G28 reference is a sensor where the nossle is touching (voron 2.4 has a sensor at the back) this is a rough Z, because of thermal expension etc the bed may be higher

for the bedmesh i use the bedmesh parameter zero_reference_position: 175, 175 and do then a probe on that position and then say this is Z= 0. might change that to this SET_Z_FROM_PROBE MEHTOD=tap seems allot easier.