3D Printers with Preinstalled and Modified Klipper Versions

Knowledge Base
1

Rationale

With the growing popularity of Klipper as a firmware option for high-speed, high-quality 3D printing, some Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) have started shipping 3D printers with preinstalled, modified versions of Klipper. These modifications are often made to:

  • Support for the specific hardware configuration.
  • Provide customized features or interfaces.
  • Integrate OEM-specific tools and UI elements tailored to the device.

While these preinstalled versions can provide a more seamless experience for users out-of-the-box, they also bring unique challenges and risks due to the alterations made by the manufacturer. Understanding these issues is essential for users who rely on community support or who may wish to update or troubleshoot their firmware.

Result of the Modifications

The OEM-modified Klipper versions can differ significantly from the standard Klipper firmware, leading to unique issues:

  1. Unexpected Printer Behavior:

    • Modified versions may change the default settings, commands, or behavior of Klipper.
    • These modifications can result in unexpected printer performance that deviates from what users might expect based on standard Klipper documentation.

  2. Incompatibility with Community Resources:

    • Since the OEM firmware may diverge from the official Klipper codebase, common troubleshooting resources, documentation, and community advice available online may not be applicable.
    • This can lead to confusion, as well-meaning advice from forums or documentation may not work as intended or could even exacerbate issues.

  3. Risk of System Breakage on Update:

    • Applying updates directly from the Klipper repository (or other sources) can conflict with OEM modifications, potentially causing the firmware to become unstable or even breaking the system entirely.
    • The OEM-provided version might contain custom drivers, UI elements, or settings that are incompatible with the latest vanilla Klipper releases, which can lead to irreversible issues if updated incorrectly.

  4. Dependency on OEM for Updates:

    • Users may become reliant on the manufacturer for firmware updates rather than benefiting from the latest Klipper features as they are released.
    • This can create delays in receiving improvements, bug fixes, or security patches until the OEM decides to release an updated version.

Support Challenges

Supporting printers with these modified Klipper versions can be uniquely challenging for several reasons:

  1. Lack of Access to OEM Hardware:

    • Community supporters often do not have access to every OEM-modified setup, making it difficult to provide accurate help without owning or fully understanding the specific device.
    • The modified firmware could obscure troubleshooting paths, making standard solutions ineffective or even harmful.

  2. Unclear or Undocumented Modifications:

    • OEMs may not fully disclose or document the modifications they make to Klipper, leaving users and support communities in the dark.
    • Without detailed change logs or documentation, it becomes difficult to diagnose or correct issues caused by these modifications.

  3. Recommendation to Stick to OEM-Provided Firmware:

    • Given the risks and limitations, the best course of action for users of these printers is often to:
      • Stick with the OEM-provided Klipper version.
      • Wait for updates directly from the manufacturer rather than attempting to apply vanilla Klipper updates.
    • This approach ensures that the firmware remains stable and avoids compatibility issues, though it may limit access to the latest features and improvements.

Résumé

  1. Awareness before purchase:

    • Users should inform themselves before buying such printers
    • Are there any changes to vanilla Klipper and if so, what kind of changes? Especially hardware that is not supported by vanilla Klipper can quickly become a long-term burden.
    • Are the changes known, documented and public or might they even violate the Klipper licence?
    • Is the OEM expected to provide long term support for his product or is it rather pushed to the market but obviously lacking constant updates or product support?

  2. Support Expectations:

    • Supporters here often “only” know the official mainline Klipper and may not feel able to help with the modified versions. In addition, the effort and time required to analyze the unexpected behavior may be considered too much for the volunteers.
    • Often the best place to turn to in the case of an unexpected behavior is the OEM of the 3D printer.
    • In the case of additional licensing concerns, support will be denied anyway, as this behavior is not accepted and damages the whole OSS idea and community.
6 Likes